
Touchphonics
— Interview with Dr. Robin Steed
Part 4 of 4
Okay, how dramatic is the difference?
If phonics is their problem, students can usually make a fluency growth of two
grade levels, and that's dramatic! What I have found that is so wonderful, is
that these kids after just a few sessions, recognize their own progress and you
can see their confidence and self-esteem grow.
Are the student teachers in the BYU program reading specialists?
No, they are pre-service teachers, undergraduate students who are learning
what to do about reading problems as they're working with their at-risk children.
What period of time do your student teachers spend with
a child?
Although the total semester classwork is about sixteen weeks, they only have
six or seven weeks to actually teach with the Touchphonics letter trays.
Now, once you've spent the six or seven weeks teaching
phonics this way, does the child need more instruction?
We never have to reteach word structure principles again. It's like a laser
beam for a tumor. They don't need to be retaught that words are made of parts
which you blend together, or that you match the sound to the symbol and you
can substitute the parts.
During this six to seven week period, how many hours
of instruction are you talking about?
I'm talking one hour, three consecutive days a week. Now they do not use the
whole hour to teach phonics. They teach an awful lot of fluency, with maybe
only fifteen or twenty minutes on Touchphonics and then about twenty minutes
of using that information in context, reading print. If phonics is the problem,
a student will generally make two years growth in fluency within the six or
seven week period.
How many children have been taught by your student teachers
using this system?
Oh, probably more than two thousand in the last six years.
Is there a time when it's too late to use the Touchphonics
system?
No, I have this program running in a community college for adults. In fact,
Sarah Johnson, a BYU graduate student, did a well controlled study for her
thesis on the comparative effectiveness of three teaching methods. She used
54 ESL adults from about 17 to 50 years old. Each one was randomly selected
from the BYU English Language Center and then randomly assigned to one of three
teaching methods: traditional, no method, and the Touchphonics system. They
were each given a prerecorded pretest followed by 30 minutes of treatment and
a prerecorded post-test. The data was analyzed using an analysis of covariance.
She concluded that the Touchphonics system was far superior to the other methods
with a probability value less than 0.0005. These are similar to the results
I got in my studies. The system has also been used effectively on older children
in junior high who were struggling with reading.
Do these older kids require more time than say a first
or third grader?
No, it takes much less time because they usually have a better understanding
of how to use the context to recognize words.
Have you used the Touchphonics system with kids who have
dyslexia?
Yes, in fact my original work was designed to help severe dyslexia. We have
also used Touchphonics successfully with kids who have cerebral palsy, attention
deficit disorders and mild intellectual handicaps.

|